| PLAYER | POS | TEAM | |
| 1) | Peyton Manning | QB | Indianapolis |
| 2) | BALTIMORE | D | |
| 3) | Matt Stover | K | Baltimore |
| 4) | Donte Stallworth | WR | Philadelphia |
| 5) | Thomas Jones | RB | Chicago |
| 6) | Vincent Jackson | WR | San Diego |
| 7) | Marion Barber | RB | Dallas |
| 8) | Steve Gostkowski | K | New England |
| 9) | LJ Smith | TE | Philadelphia |
| 10) | Martin Gramatica | K | Dallas |